Shows I thought I'd hate but actually loved:
Babylon 5Why I thought I'd hate it: "Great, another space station show." Where I lived at the time, it aired on the same channel immediately after Star Trek: Deep Space 9, one of my three least favorite ST franchises.
Why I liked it instead: good acting (amongst the regulars - the extras sometimes stunk), excellent writing, an actual story arc instead of just stand-alone episodes, and *gasp* social and political conflicts that were not neatly resolved by the end of an hour, minus commercials. Plus the special effects were awesome for a TV show at the time.
Veronica MarsWhy I thought I'd hate it: for some reason, I thought it was a 30 minute girly teenie sitcom.
Why I liked it instead: everything I thought about it was so far off it applies equally to The Shield, Jeopardy and Monday Night Football with as much accuracy. The show was an hour-long edgy PI thingy with a lot of overtones of class discrimination, only set mostly at school starring the cute bunny-sized non-bunny Kristen Bell.
DexterWhy I thought I'd hate it: shows and movies never live up to the books upon which they're based.
Why I liked it instead: the writing in the show is actually better. The titular character is less consistent than in the book, but I think the change was a good idea and necessary to make the character interesting enough to carry a series and palatable for the general public. In the show, he refers to himself as a monster but demonstrates he is capable of caring and growing emotionally. In the book, he is defined by his inability to do those things. Note - the first book and first season are somewhat similar for about the first half, then diverge and go in completely separate directions so you can enjoy both without one being a retread of the other.
Sons of AnarchyWhy I thought I'd hate it: while lying in a hospital bed for a week, I saw the same commercial for this show over and over and Over and OVER and
OVER!!! And the dialog, taken out of context, sounded like horrible drivel being delivered by people reading cue cards (poorly).
Why I liked it instead: for some reason I watched an actual episode. AWESOME! It's funny and touching and violent, the dialog is great, and yes, one character does have a very wooden way of speaking, but you realize it fits his personality when you see an entire episode and not the same two lines of dialog spoken at you 37,124 times per day as you lay in an uncomfortable sick bed waiting for the next needle stick.
Shows I thought I'd love but actually hated:
Arrested DevelopmentWhy I thought I'd like it: edgy comedy showcasing bad people doing bad things. Recommended for people who enjoyed Better Off Ted.
Why I disliked it instead: the core of the plot revolves around around a monumentally dysfunctional family. I've lived that for about 35 years and then partially extricated myself (although you will never, ever, ever run out of people wanting to know more about your family who will feel prompted to field another thousand questions when you say "we're estranged" or something else conveying that the subject is uncomfortable to you and you'd rather move on), and the topic always annoys me to the point that I can't appreciate whatever else it has to offer.
Six Feet UnderWhy I thought I'd like it: lots of recommendations and comparisons to other shows I like.
Why I disliked it instead: see Arrested Development above. Also, very well written and acted but otherwise nothing like the other shows I like.
Glee
Why I thought I'd like it: good word of mouth and promises that it was filled with wacky.
Why I disliked it instead: actually I'm on the fence about this one. It didn't provide the level of wacky I'd heard, but the main thing was that it's the only show I've ever watched that made me feel like I would have appreciated it 25 years ago but now I'm just too old to "get it" or care that I don't. After digging Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Veronica Mars, Zim the Invader and Justice League Unlimited, that was an unexpected reaction. I think I'll give the second disc a try to see how it goes.
As usual, if your opinion differs from mine then it's proof I am the superior being and Jesus will pop out your eyes and skull fuck you in the afterlife